In “The Myth of Icarus”, Icarus, full of the folly that comes with pride, flew too high and the sun melted his wings.
Dr Caroline Leaf is the modern day Christian version of Icarus, foolishly flying higher and higher, deluded by her self-importance and unaware of the weakness and fissuring of her presumed competence.
But unlike the myth of Icarus where only Icarus himself paid the ultimate price, Dr Leaf isn’t the only person flying too close to the sun, but she is encouraging the church to follow her lead.
Dr Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist and self-titled cognitive neuroscientist. Unfortunately, despite no training or experience whatsoever in psychiatry, psychology or even basic counselling, Dr Leaf has assumed the role of a mental health expert for the church.
Having the untrained Dr Leaf lecture Christian congregations on mental illness is an absolutely absurd proposition – it’s like having a plumber give a public lecture about coronary bypass surgery. Yet the uncredentialed Dr Leaf continues to speak at church after church after church about mental health and illness, given a free license as if she were a psychiatrist with decades of experience.
And my question is “Why”?
Why do pastors and church leaders give Dr Leaf a free pass to speak from their platforms on a subject that she is objectively unqualified to speak on? Where is the public process of due diligence? Where is public demonstration of accountability that undergirds the reverence, the sacred gravitas, of the church pulpit? Why do our church leaders stay silent when unqualified preachers poison their congregations with saccharine subterfuge?
Where are all the shepherds? Why aren’t they shepherding?
Dr Leaf’s latest e-mail newsletter aptly demonstrates what the church needs protecting from – an entire e-mail encouraging people to withdraw from psychiatric medications. Her bias is clear – psychiatric medications are harmful and you can withdraw from them if you want to. If you do, you’ll feel better.
This might as well be unsolicited, unlicensed medical advice. There’s no discussion about the nuances of psychotropic medication, or the proven benefits. She then encourages people to look for more information by reading books or visiting websites that are known to be unhinged or, at best, clearly biased against medications for mental ill-health.
In the past, Dr Leaf has clearly shown her ignorance when it comes to psychiatric medications. She has accused them of everything from being poisonous to being unspiritual. Never once has she acknowledged the scores of research papers that confirm the judicious use of psychiatric medications saves lives and extends the lifespan of those who take them.
Now, she has advised people that they can stop their medications and promotes unscrupulous and biased sources of information to help. This isn’t just ignorant, this is dangerous. 
Will it take the untimely death of one of their congregation before our church leaders say ‘enough is enough’? It will be all too late then.
It’s time for our church leaders to stand up for the congregations they lead and denounce the teaching of Dr Caroline Leaf. Her ignorance and her arrogance are becoming a dangerous mix. Our pastors can’t wait until blood is on their hands before they’re forced into action – they need to act now, before it’s too late.
If you are concerned about the medications you’re taking or you think you don’t need them any more, for heaven’s sake don’t just stop taking them or try and wean yourself. Go see your doctor for advice specific to your medication and your situation.
DISCLAIMER: Just in case anyone was wondering about my motives, I declare that I have no connection with any pharmaceutical company. I do not accept gratuities of any form from any sales representative. I don’t eat their food, I don’t take their pens, and I don’t listen to their sales pitches.
References and bibliography
 Valuck RJ, Orton HD, Libby AM. Antidepressant discontinuation and risk of suicide attempt: a retrospective, nested case-control study. J Clin Psychiatry 2009 Aug;70(8):1069-77.